A Way of Life

Sep 30
Part One of Five — A Way of Life Series.

A Way of Life.
Seventeen percent of Americans rate #realestate agents as honest. Gallup has measured it for decades, and the profession sits near the bottom, below bankers. The industry treats that number as a public relations nuisance. It is a verdict, and it was earned by the way of life the industry built, sold and defended.

Look at that life honestly. The early starts, the phone that never goes quiet, the weekends given away, the constant performance of being fine. Then ask the question nobody in the industry wants to be asked.

Is this the life you signed up for?  A game with no referee?
Real estate is built as a contest with one instruction:
Win. Win the listing. Win the sale. Win the month. Nobody defines what winning is allowed to cost, so the people most willing to pay that cost pull ahead.

That is not an accident of a few unlucky offices. Someone designed a "Hot Buyers" board that ranked purchasers by the extra revenue they would generate, not by what they offered for the house. Someone designed a kicker commission that paid up to five times the base rate once a sale cleared a threshold. Someone designed a bonus for talking sellers into price drops after their home had been overvalued to win the listing in the first place. Each of these was a spreadsheet, approved in a meeting, by adults in charge of real businesses. Accountable to shareholders, not to clients.

When the only rule is to come out ahead, cheating stops being a deviation. It becomes the strategy, and the strategy that works gets copied. A former agency employee, looking back on his early career, described the mood plainly.

"We knew it was morally incorrect."  -  Former estate agency employee, speaking to The Intermediary.
He knew. His colleagues knew. They did it anyway, because the game was designed so that the person who hesitated fell behind the person who didn't.
"The winner is still a rat." (Lily Tomlin)

Walk into an agency and find the leaderboard. Top producer this month. Most listings this quarter. Somebody's name in gold, somebody else's name at the bottom, and everyone in the room watching both.

Now ask what the person at the top actually won. A bigger number to beat next month. A tighter grip on a phone that already owns them. A place at the front of a race that has no finish line, run inside a wheel that only turns faster. A rat race does not become dignified because you lead it. The winner is still a rat, running harder than everyone else, on the same wheel, going nowhere.

Is this the life you signed up for?

Comparison is the thief of joy.

The leaderboard is only the visible part. The rest lives in your pocket. The "Just Sold" posts, the awards photos, the agent down the road with a bigger billboard and a better year. Every agent in this industry is measured against every other agent, all day, from every direction, and the measurement never lets anybody feel finished.

Comparison steals joy because it moves the goalposts every time you approach them. The agent who had a career-best quarter spends the celebration checking who beat them. This is not motivation. It is a slow, well-organised way of making sure nobody is ever satisfied, and a person who is never satisfied is exactly the person who will cut the next corner.

The homeowner cannot judge you.
Here is the part the industry keeps quiet about. The person hiring an agent usually cannot tell a competent one from an incompetent one. They sell a home once every decade or so. They have no yardstick, no training, no way to check the advice they are given until the deal is finished and the damage, if any, is done.

So what do they judge on? What they can see. The highest valuation. The lowest fee. The confident voice, the sharp suit, the sign on the lawn. None of those measure competence. An agent who promises the most wins the listing over the agent who tells the truth about the price, and the market has just taught everyone watching which of those two to become.

A contest judged by people who cannot see what they are judging will reward performance over substance every single time. The agents who survive are the ones who learned to perform.

Is this the life you signed up for?

The clique, the burn-out and the commodity.

Every industry has its inner circle. Real estate has a particularly tight one: the top producers, the franchise heads, the awards circuit, the people on stage. They decide what a good agent looks like, and everybody else conforms. Same scripts. Same dashboards. Same calendar. Same pitch delivered in the same voice, because deviation gets you frozen out of the room where the referrals are handed around.

That conformity is sold as a way of life. For a great many people, it is a way of burning out. They pour years into a pace no human being can hold, and when they crack, the industry does not ask what it did to them. It replaces them.

And what is left, after all that effort to fit the mould? A commodity. Thousands of agents saying identical things in identical ways, indistinguishable to the homeowner, who reasonably concludes the only thing left to compare is the fee. The clique that demanded sameness then wonders why nobody can charge for being different.

The coaches who never left.

You might expect someone to step in with a wider view. Enter the coaching industry, staffed largely by people who have never worked anywhere else. They were agents. They had a good run. They became Regional Directors. They became redundant. They became coaches. Their entire understanding of business, of people and of success was formed inside the same closed system they are now hired to fix.

So they teach the scripts they used. They repeat the targets they chased. They recommend the tactics that worked in their market, in their decade, on their clients, and they have no outside experience to test any of it against. It is an echo chamber with an invoice. The agent pays to hear the industry's own assumptions said back to them, louder, by someone with a microphone.

Nothing in that loop ever asks whether the game itself is worth playing. The people who might ask have never seen another one.

Is this the life you signed up for?

What this series follows.
Everything above is the operating system. The next four pieces show what it runs. Where it lands on the client, who stops being the person served and becomes the ground two competing interests fight over. Where it lands on the industry's own staff, who get the same disposal the culture teaches agents to give the market. Where it ends for a smaller number, in a courtroom, because ruthlessness pushed far enough eventually runs out of room. And last, what an alternative to all of it looks like in practice.

Seventeen percent is not a branding problem. It is the sound of an industry that made winning the whole point, and it is not going to be fixed by a better slogan, a bigger leaderboard or another coach who has never worked anywhere else.
Created with