What If Every Flavour Was Vanilla?

Aug 22
What If Every Flavour Was Vanilla?
Not every flavour is for everyone. That's not a flaw in the ice cream case, it's the entire point of having more than one tub in it. Pistachio isn't trying to convert the vanilla people. It's just waiting for the ones who were always going to want pistachio.

Now imagine a stranger version of that shop. One where every manufacturer, every franchise, every training seminar on how to run an ice cream business, all agreed on the same flavour. Vanilla. Not because it's the best flavour. Because it's the easiest one to teach at scale, the easiest one to put in a script, the easiest one to franchise across a thousand locations without anybody needing an actual palate.
That's the real estate coaching industry. That's Tom Ferry's systems, Tom Panos's call scripts, Ricky Carruth's daily-habits gospel, all training a generation of agents into the same flavour. Same opening line. Same objection handling. Same follow-up cadence, timed to the same day. Not because it's the flavour their market actually wants. Because it's the flavour that's trainable.

"Brand is not what you say it is. It's what they say it is."
— Marty Neumeier
Here's the quiet cost of that. When every agent in a market sounds like they graduated from the same script, the client stops being able to tell them apart on anything except price. That's not an accident. That's what sameness always produces. Homeowners can't select for character when every flavour on offer is identical, so they select for the only variable left, which is the commission.

The coaching industry needs agents to be interchangeable.

Interchangeable agents need the coach forever, because nothing about them is memorable enough to stand on its own once the training wheels come off. That's the dependency, and it's built in on purpose. A pistachio agent doesn't need a vanilla factory.

And when someone finally does complain about the sameness, the industry has an answer ready. Add sprinkles. Get a flake. Here's a logo, here's a tagline, here's a colour scheme, here's the branded bio template. But vanilla with sprinkles and vanilla with a chocolate flake aren't two flavours. They're one flavour wearing two different hats. That's the coaching in the proverbial cone — decoration sold as differentiation, so the agent feels seen without the industry ever having to touch the base underneath. The scoop never changed. Only the topping did.

Character is the flavour the industry can't manufacture, which is exactly why it can't be commoditized either. It's also why it's terrifying to a business built on scale. A script can be copied by anyone with a subscription. Congruence can't. Nobody can license being actually who they say they are.

This is not a case for being difficult, or being deliberately strange to stand out. It's a case for letting the flavour be the flavour, instead of sanding it down until it matches every other tub in the case. Some clients will walk right past it. Good. That was never your market anyway. The ones who stop are the ones who were always going to buy.

Worth knowing, not simply well known, was never a slogan. It was a rejection of vanilla.

Find Your Flavour:  https://thebrandwithin.me

Be worth knowing, not simply well known.
Created with